If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
Went to Firestone today because I have a slow leak in one of my tires.
The car is a 2002 Subaru Impreza TS with factory spec tires 195/60/R15. Turns out the slow leak was due to a puncture in the sidewall of the tire, so that tire is garbage. The tires are all about a year old and have decent meat on them, but the tech said you can't just replace one tire on an AWD car, you have to replace all 4 as a set, because the new one will be some sixteenths of an inch larger than all the rest. Of course he'd say that Now, I understand the concept and theory of this- if all wheels are the same circumference, they all rotate the same amount and internal drivetrain components (center diff or viscous clutch) don't have to take up the slack. But... I have a hard time believing that an amount measured in sixteenths of an inch is significant. Surely a few pounds of pressure off, or an unbalanced load (i.e., some fatass sitting in a seat opposite some 80 pound child) would make just as much difference? I declined to make any purchase at this time. I know I'll need to replace that one tire, but I have another vehicle to drive for now. I would like to replace the one tire only. Replacing all 4 is a bit unnecessary, right? Thanks -J |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
On Jan 10, 8:51*am, phaeton > wrote:
> Went to Firestone today because I have a slow leak in one of my tires. > The car is a 2002 Subaru Impreza TS with factory spec tires 195/60/R15. > * Turns out the slow leak was due to a puncture in the sidewall of the > tire, so that tire is garbage. *The tires are all about a year old and > have decent meat on them, but the tech said you can't just replace one > tire on an AWD car, you have to replace all 4 as a set, because the new > one will be some sixteenths of an inch larger than all the rest. > > Of course he'd say that > because that's what FHI requires. > Now, I understand the concept and theory of this- *if all wheels are the > same circumference, they all rotate the same amount and internal > drivetrain components (center diff or viscous clutch) don't have to take > up the slack. *But... I have a hard time believing that an amount > measured in sixteenths of an inch is significant. *Surely a few pounds > of pressure off, or an unbalanced load (i.e., some fatass sitting in a > seat opposite some 80 pound child) would make just as much difference? > > I declined to make any purchase at this time. *I know I'll need to > replace that one tire, but I have another vehicle to drive for now. *I > would like to replace the one tire only. *Replacing all 4 is a bit > unnecessary, right? That's what you'd like to believe. But it is does not make it right. If it makes you feel better I see subarus and quattro outfitted audis run on single axle brake force testing contraptions right and left. (during annual technical "inspections" for example) I never saw a gadget for testing brakes in a US of A auto shop, not the one that spins two tires at the time (ruining awd hardware on subarus). I specifically do not buy a used subaru because of the cheapskates like you: one never knows what thew center diff was subjected to. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
On Jan 10, 8:51*am, phaeton > wrote:
> Went to Firestone today because I have a slow leak in one of my tires. > The car is a 2002 Subaru Impreza TS with factory spec tires 195/60/R15. > * Turns out the slow leak was due to a puncture in the sidewall of the > tire, so that tire is garbage. *The tires are all about a year old and > have decent meat on them, but the tech said you can't just replace one > tire on an AWD car, you have to replace all 4 as a set, because the new > one will be some sixteenths of an inch larger than all the rest. > > Of course he'd say that > > Now, I understand the concept and theory of this- *if all wheels are the > same circumference, they all rotate the same amount and internal > drivetrain components (center diff or viscous clutch) don't have to take > up the slack. *But... I have a hard time believing that an amount > measured in sixteenths of an inch is significant. *Surely a few pounds > of pressure off, or an unbalanced load (i.e., some fatass sitting in a > seat opposite some 80 pound child) would make just as much difference? > > I declined to make any purchase at this time. *I know I'll need to > replace that one tire, but I have another vehicle to drive for now. *I > would like to replace the one tire only. *Replacing all 4 is a bit > unnecessary, right? > > Thanks > > -J I immediately thought of a guy here who run mismatched tires on front and back axles of a quattro audi (torsen based one, not haldex crap based one obviously). the drivetrain was making all sorts of noise to a point that snake oil salesmen offered to ditch the driveshaft essentially converting the car to fwd. all the noise was gone once the guy had installed 4 matching tires audi requires. the drivetrain on subaru would've been probably ruined by the same treatment but torsen seem to take this kind of abuse better, or so i would like to believe |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
phaeton wrote:
> Went to Firestone today because I have a slow leak in one of my tires. > The car is a 2002 Subaru Impreza TS with factory spec tires 195/60/R15. > Turns out the slow leak was due to a puncture in the sidewall of the > tire, so that tire is garbage. The tires are all about a year old and > have decent meat on them, but the tech said you can't just replace one > tire on an AWD car, you have to replace all 4 as a set, because the new > one will be some sixteenths of an inch larger than all the rest. > > Of course he'd say that > > Now, I understand the concept and theory of this- if all wheels are the > same circumference, they all rotate the same amount and internal > drivetrain components (center diff or viscous clutch) don't have to take > up the slack. But... I have a hard time believing that an amount > measured in sixteenths of an inch is significant. Surely a few pounds > of pressure off, or an unbalanced load (i.e., some fatass sitting in a > seat opposite some 80 pound child) would make just as much difference? > > I declined to make any purchase at this time. I know I'll need to > replace that one tire, but I have another vehicle to drive for now. I > would like to replace the one tire only. Replacing all 4 is a bit > unnecessary, right? > > Thanks > > -J With AWD you replace all 4 at the same time. The "concept" is reality on an AWD vehicle. -- Steve W. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
On 1/10/2012 1:29 AM, Steve W. wrote:
> > With AWD you replace all 4 at the same time. > > The "concept" is reality on an AWD vehicle. > > Well then. It is what it is. Is it possible to buy a new tire and have the tire shop shave the tread down to match the other three? Wasteful as it is, it seems like a proper solution. Otherwise, I'll replace all four. Thanks. -J |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
Have you considered fitting an inner tube to the tyre with the leak?
"phaeton" > wrote in message ... > Went to Firestone today because I have a slow leak in one of my tires. The > car is a 2002 Subaru Impreza TS with factory spec tires 195/60/R15. Turns > out the slow leak was due to a puncture in the sidewall of the tire, so > that tire is garbage. The tires are all about a year old and have decent > meat on them, but the tech said you can't just replace one tire on an AWD > car, you have to replace all 4 as a set, because the new one will be some > sixteenths of an inch larger than all the rest. > > Of course he'd say that > > Now, I understand the concept and theory of this- if all wheels are the > same circumference, they all rotate the same amount and internal > drivetrain components (center diff or viscous clutch) don't have to take > up the slack. But... I have a hard time believing that an amount measured > in sixteenths of an inch is significant. Surely a few pounds of pressure > off, or an unbalanced load (i.e., some fatass sitting in a seat opposite > some 80 pound child) would make just as much difference? > > I declined to make any purchase at this time. I know I'll need to replace > that one tire, but I have another vehicle to drive for now. I would like > to replace the one tire only. Replacing all 4 is a bit unnecessary, > right? > > Thanks > > -J |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
phaeton wrote:
> On 1/10/2012 1:29 AM, Steve W. wrote: > > >> With AWD you replace all 4 at the same time. >> >> The "concept" is reality on an AWD vehicle. >> >> > > Well then. It is what it is. Is it possible to buy a new tire and have > the tire shop shave the tread down to match the other three? > > Wasteful as it is, it seems like a proper solution. Otherwise, I'll > replace all four. > > > Thanks. > > -J A good shop should be able to shave the tread. But finding a good shop is a crap shoot some times. If you can find one that does race tires or handles a lot of ricers you would probably find a shaver that knew the work. -- Steve W. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
On Jan 10, 3:47*am, phaeton > wrote:
> On 1/10/2012 1:29 AM, Steve W. wrote: > > > > > With AWD you replace all 4 at the same time. > > > The "concept" is reality on an AWD vehicle. > > Well then. *It is what it is. *Is it possible to buy a new tire and have > the tire shop shave the tread down to match the other three? > > Wasteful as it is, it seems like a proper solution. *Otherwise, I'll > replace all four. > > Thanks. > > -J Yes. But you'll probably have to find a race shop to do the shaving. And they will refuse to do it once the tire has actually been operated on the street (because the rubber of the tire tread will pick up debris that will destroy the knife on their machine,) so you would need to take the tire over to them in the trunk of another vehicle (possibly with one of the old tires so they can measure the tread depth on it with the same gauge that they're going to use when they shave your new tire.) Where are you? If you are in NoVA I can ask around, I have some contacts that might know where to have this done. good luck nate |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
"AB" > wrote in message ... > Have you considered fitting an inner tube to the tyre with the leak? DING DING DING No more calls, we have a winner with the obvious answer. This practice was common once, years ago, but the lemmings have since been easily convinced that they need to replace the tire. Yes you'll get more heat buildup but somehow I suspect you're not racing that greyhound and that will never be the slightest issue for you. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
AWD car needs a new tire; Replace one or all 4
On Jan 10, 1:51*am, phaeton > wrote:
> Replacing all 4 is a bit unnecessary, right? "Here are recommendations from some of the manufactures that Tire Rack currently serves for matching the tires used on their four-wheel drive and all-wheel drive vehicles. Subaru- Within 1/4-inch of tire circumference or about 2/32-inch of each other in remaining tread depth." http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tirete...jsp?techid=18& ----- - gpsman |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
rear wheel biased awd options for a family car, station wagon or aminivan | Squat n'Dive | BMW | 10 | March 1st 10 04:00 PM |
Car dealer: Bad wheel alignment is typical in AWD cars | 223rem[_2_] | Driving | 9 | August 27th 08 09:35 PM |
2003 Grand Caravan AWD - AWD not working. | [email protected] | Dodge | 0 | December 10th 05 01:52 PM |
New tire, replace two? | [email protected] | Technology | 6 | June 2nd 05 05:54 PM |
Subaru AWD...replace all tires? | kingtone | Technology | 2 | May 26th 05 02:35 PM |