If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
Ads |
#42
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
pws > wrote in
: > Will a good driver in a Mustang beat a poor driver in a miata on a > twisty track? Of course they will. That is obvious. Not obvious at all, not even true maybe. "Good driver", "poor driver" and "twisty track" are relative terms. How good is the Mustang driver? How poor it the Miata driver? How twisty is the track? I think you've made too broad a generalization... |
#43
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
XS11E wrote:
> > Not obvious at all, not even true maybe. "Good driver", "poor driver" > and "twisty track" are relative terms. How good is the Mustang driver? > How poor it the Miata driver? How twisty is the track? > > I think you've made too broad a generalization... Ok, no argument here. I am guilty as charged. To clarify, I am referring to a really good driver in the Mustang, not necessarily competition level but someone who knows what they are doing versus someone in the miata who is such a complete novice, or just so bad, that they are as likely to end up sliding off of the track as they are to finish the race. Dave pointed out that it was the driver that mattered. I was simply agreeing with this statement to an extent, a better driver can win a race in a slower car, unless the difference is extreme as as in the case of my Tercel versus Corvette example. This is assuming that the Corvette driver can stay on the track, but that shouldn't be too hard to do if all you have to do is beat a Tercel. :-) Pat - off to bed, finally. With a predicted high of 83 tomorrow, a full tank of gas, and the day off, I know what I'll be doing. |
#44
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
Lanny Chambers wrote:
> In article >, > wrote: > > >>That "handling through the turns business" is mostly done at 35 to 55 >>mph, yes? What's up with that? > > > I dunno--perhaps limited expectations, or a compulsion to obey speed > laws? If the road is dry, the tires are first-rate, and the driver has > had some training, as a rule he can double the number on most yellow > "SAFE SPEED" signs and still have enough reserve capability to deal > safely with the unexpected. Miatas are not fast...but they don't have to > slow down as much or as often as most cars. > > You should take your Miata to a track education day and discover what it > can do. I think you underestimate its potential. > I have seen the most ridiculous example so far. There is a curve at some road construction where the sign recommends slowing down to 10 mph. Large construction trucks take it at 25 to 30 mph. I went through it at 55 mph and still had lots of reserve, so you could probably take that one at 7 or 8 times the suggested speed. :-) Pat |
#45
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
Lanny Chambers > wrote in
: > I dunno--perhaps limited expectations, or a compulsion to obey > speed laws? If the road is dry, the tires are first-rate, and the > driver has had some training, as a rule he can double the number > on most yellow "SAFE SPEED" signs and still have enough reserve > capability to deal safely with the unexpected. Wrong, you may deal with the unexpected but what about the expected? Going fast will irritate Mr. Policeman and when he's irritated the ears on his horse will turn red and that will cause severe injury to your wallet (don't ask how I know this!) so to be safe, drive so as not to irritate Mr. Policeman. |
#46
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
On 2005-11-14, XS11E > wrote:
> Lanny Chambers > wrote in > : > >> I dunno--perhaps limited expectations, or a compulsion to obey >> speed laws? If the road is dry, the tires are first-rate, and the >> driver has had some training, as a rule he can double the number >> on most yellow "SAFE SPEED" signs and still have enough reserve >> capability to deal safely with the unexpected. > > Wrong, you may deal with the unexpected but what about the expected? > Going fast will irritate Mr. Policeman and when he's irritated the ears > on his horse will turn red and that will cause severe injury to your > wallet (don't ask how I know this!) so to be safe, drive so as not to > irritate Mr. Policeman. In the states I've lived in, the yellow "speed" signs at curves are not regulatory. -- Grant Edwards grante Yow! We just joined the at civil hair patrol! visi.com |
#47
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
In article >, pws > wrote:
>Dave wrote: First, let me say I think we agree on more than we'll admit. But I do think that we have a little too much faith in our trusty Miatas. >I agree that the power is an advantage, but how does the weight help? It doesn't. Never said it did. Miata owners, me included, worship at the "add lightness" temple (noting your Elise comment and I too want one). Yes, light is good. But I think we all overestimate it. But I submit power/weight is by far the biggest component in racing after the driver (assuming a decently sorted suspension). Sure, make it light and you've solved the equation. So does adding power. Next, any lightweight-disciple will say "yeah, but light makes for better cornering and braking". To an extent, I agree. But you can make anything brake and corner with great tires, big brakes, and a well-sorted suspension. "But they all add weight...". Yes, but you can still make that up with added hp. Vipers, GT CTS-V race cars, and many others go very, very fast and still weigh 3500 lbs. Listen, I don't want to argue myself into a corner, so I'll state "YES, LIGHT IS GOOD". But it isn't going to make up for a ****-poor power/weight *on a race track*. Look at that Automobile article where they had 9 track cars. The Elise finished mid-pack. http://www.elisetalk.com/forums/showthread. php?s=&threadid=3270&highlight=automobile+magazine Further, frankly, I think we overestimate the Miata's handling. It has *fun* handling. Nice balance, lots of feel, good stick (rubber-dependent). But out of the box, too much roll, too much weight transfer (though it makes it fun). Yes, aftermarket can address all that ... as it can with a Mustang. On the road, any of these cars is a lot more capable than what we do with them. If not, you are a danger (sand, oil, deer, bicyclist ...). Honestly, I have no idea how well a stock Mustang GT handles. I wouldn't believe what I read here anyway. Most everyone says their car handles great. And will say the other guy's (especially American cars) suck. But handling is so subjective it is a near-meaningless statement. Bottom line, I'd look for the same very competent driver running both a Miata and a Mustang GT stock. My bet: on a track other than auto-X, no contest. I don't have any proof, but here's an interesting article ... http://www.edmunds. com/insideline/do/Features/articleId=107486?flushCache=true We all agree the RX-8 is a fine handling car akin to the Miata? And it has much better power/weight, so it should be faster on the track? Well, here's three drivers of very different ability levels lapping it and the Mustang GT (and others). They were all about 3 sec a lap faster in the junky Ford than the RX-8. Certainly not conclusive, but doesn't it make one stop and reconsider their preconceptions? I still prefer my Miata. But I wouldn't diss anyone who either (a) prefers the Mustang or (b) wants to add power to their Miata. My apologies for the long-winder post ... if you got here ... |
#48
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
Dave,
I think that we are basically on the same page here. I know that in one magazine article of the fastest modified cars, there wasn't a small car to be found. I think that they measured acceleration, braking, lap times, and a few other tests and came up with the car with the best overall abilities, which was a very highly modified Corvette, iirc. They still haven't gotten a miata to do 200 mph, a rather easy achievement for some car models, so I agree that it is not a *high-speed* car, even when modified. I do, however, have to smile anytime I see this picture. http://home.austin.rr.com/sheltonser...pers-miata.jpg A muscle car driving friend of mine says that it is just a shot of the Vipers lapping the Miata, but I think we know better. :-) Have fun and be safe! I just did. Pat |
#49
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
Dave wrote:
> > http://www.edmunds. > com/insideline/do/Features/articleId=107486?flushCache=true Here is a working link to the article using Tinyurl. http://tinyurl.com/a6ddf Pat |
#50
|
|||
|
|||
Basic Horsepower Upgrades
In article >,
XS11E > wrote: > Going fast will irritate Mr. Policeman and when he's irritated the ears > on his horse will turn red and that will cause severe injury to your > wallet (don't ask how I know this!) so to be safe, drive so as not to > irritate Mr. Policeman. There's a time and place for everything. If a driver can't tell the difference...well, think of Mr. Policeman as an agent of natural selection. :-) If there are no fun, unpatrolled roads where you live, then move! -- Lanny Chambers '94C, St. Louis http://www.hummingbirds.net/alignment.html |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
20+ Horsepower Increase for your BMW. RaceMOD Performance chip only $29.99 | RaceMOD | BMW | 6 | November 6th 05 05:00 AM |
Why you should never buy a car without a tachometer | Ted B. | Driving | 112 | September 19th 05 04:09 AM |
Guess on horsepower??? | Willis | Technology | 10 | August 4th 05 10:37 PM |
Upgrades for '04 S4 | Pete Stolz | Audi | 1 | February 17th 05 10:13 AM |
Horsepower Still Sells | [email protected] | Ford Mustang | 1 | January 13th 05 05:45 AM |