If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
1998 Saturn SL2 timing chain
I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into
some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking timing chains. being that I only paid $1000.00 for it I am not to concerned if I have to replace it but I was just wondering if any one knows about this problem ( if it exists ) tank you for your time |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Lazarus wrote:
> I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > timing chains. I have a 98SL2 with ~75K and since I've had the car (~40K) I've never had a problem with the timing belt. I haven't heard anything like this (3 other SLs in my family), and I also don't see anything about it on the list of TSBs. BTW: does anyone know where to get the full text of the TSBs? All I can find is a list of TSB titles, except the 25$/year to alldatadyi. -rj 98SL2 |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
I've read that if the car has had normal oil changes and not allowed to run
on low oil levels, timing chain life is really long - something like the life of the engine (which means different numbers to different folks). And I've also read they start making enough noise before they fail that most techs/mechanics can suggest it's time to replace. Since the valves don't clear the tops of the piston on the compression stroke, i.e. interference engine, you'll bend and break parts when the chain breaks. Not pretty. My 97SL2 with 89,200 miles is on the original chain and is fine as far as I know - I think I hit 6,000 r's on a shift today merging onto the highway and everything stayed together... (grin) "Lazarus" > wrote in message om... > I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > timing chains. > being that I only paid $1000.00 for it I am not to concerned if I have > to replace it but I was just wondering if any one knows about this > problem ( if it exists ) tank you for your time |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
I think Jonnie has it right. Oil is the lifeblood of an engine. I have a
'94 with 157,000 miles and the chain is quiet. Since Saturns have a reputation for using oil, check it every few times you fill up your tank...until you get a feeling for how much oil you're using. My car is now using a quart every 1,500 miles. 2,000 miles when it was brand new. She's getting old.... Barry "Jonnie Santos" > wrote in message news:EcWnc.134190$Qy.41551@fed1read04... > I've read that if the car has had normal oil changes and not allowed to run > on low oil levels, timing chain life is really long - something like the > life of the engine (which means different numbers to different folks). And > I've also read they start making enough noise before they fail that most > techs/mechanics can suggest it's time to replace. Since the valves don't > clear the tops of the piston on the compression stroke, i.e. interference > engine, you'll bend and break parts when the chain breaks. Not pretty. > > My 97SL2 with 89,200 miles is on the original chain and is fine as far as I > know - I think I hit 6,000 r's on a shift today merging onto the highway and > everything stayed together... (grin) > > "Lazarus" > wrote in message > om... > > I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > > timing chains. > > being that I only paid $1000.00 for it I am not to concerned if I have > > to replace it but I was just wondering if any one knows about this > > problem ( if it exists ) tank you for your time > > |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
"richard hornsby" > wrote in message ... > Lazarus wrote: > > > I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > > timing chains. > > I have a 98SL2 with ~75K and since I've had the car (~40K) I've never > had a problem with the timing belt. I haven't heard anything like this > (3 other SLs in my family), and I also don't see anything about it on > the list of TSBs. > > BTW: does anyone know where to get the full text of the TSBs? All I > can find is a list of TSB titles, except the 25$/year to alldatadyi. > > -rj > 98SL2 No timing belt on your car. It has a timing chain. They aren't known to break. Ken |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
> No timing belt on your car. It has a timing chain. They aren't known
> to break. Apologies. I realized later that I meant chain, and not belt. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"richard hornsby" > wrote in message ... > > No timing belt on your car. It has a timing chain. They aren't known > > to break. > > Apologies. I realized later that I meant chain, and not belt. No apologies needed here. The only thing I'm concerned about is that a true neophyte (not you, you obviously have more knowledge then that) might change the serpentine belt and think they had changed a timing belt. If they were having a timing chain problem that could be a 'fatal error'. Ken |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"Lazarus" > wrote in message
om... > I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > timing chains. > being that I only paid $1000.00 for it I am not to concerned if I have > to replace it but I was just wondering if any one knows about this > problem ( if it exists ) tank you for your time It is true. See: http://groups.google.com/groups?oi=d...m=an_364666954 The same mechanic, and owner of Saturn Services (now 6th Planet after Saturn threatened litigation), a well-regarded independent Saturn shop in Florida, suggests changing the chain at 70K miles for preventive maintenance: "saturn timing chains are failing at an alarming rate, i'm recommending to my customers to replace them at 75k as preventive maintenance. were now selling apx 4 engines every week now and most are due to t-chain failures. the twin cams are failing more than the single cams f.y.i." OTOH, If you paid $1000, you're probably not going to want to spend $600-700 on a timing chain replacement, and you'll most likely go well beyond 100K miles. The odds are on your side that you won't have a failure. And as others have pointed out, a worn timing chain usually makes noise prior to failing, so you have some warning. However you don't have a frame of reference as to what the noise level should be normally, if you bought it used. Just keep the oil level topped off (you're probably burning a quart or two of oil in a Saturn that old), and you'll get your money's worth. A lot of people have been misled on this issue, a timing chain, even though it is steel, does NOT last the life of the car. As Tom and Ray state: "Timing chains do last longer, but not necessarily the life of the car. And when they do break, it's a big job and a lot of money to replace them, and "Now, with overhead-cam engines, it has to be 3 or 4 feet long, and for that kind of length, a belt is not only a lot quieter, but more reliable, too. When you use a chain for that kind of length, it's more likely to loosen up, slap around and eventually break." See http://www.cartalk.com/content/colum.../April/01.html |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
In article >,
says... > > "richard hornsby" > wrote in message > ... > > Lazarus wrote: > > > > > I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > > > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > > > timing chains. > > > > I have a 98SL2 with ~75K and since I've had the car (~40K) I've > never > > had a problem with the timing belt. I haven't heard anything like > this > > (3 other SLs in my family), and I also don't see anything about it > on > > the list of TSBs. > > > > BTW: does anyone know where to get the full text of the TSBs? All > I > > can find is a list of TSB titles, except the 25$/year to alldatadyi. > > > > -rj > > 98SL2 > > No timing belt on your car. It has a timing chain. They aren't known > to break. > > Ken Saturn timing chains in the 1.9L arent known for strength so yes they are known to break. Its a single roller chain that goes from the crank to one or two over head cam(s) so its longer than none ohc engines. I think there are many ways for these chains to go bad. One may be sticking valves which stress the chain. Lack of oil changes could result in more drag. Another thought would be a clogging oil passage that lubricates the chain. Either way frequent oil changes and not pushing the engine on a cold winter day until its warmed up can probably greatly improve the life of the chain. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
"Blah blah" > wrote in message ... > In article >, > says... > > > > "richard hornsby" > wrote in message > > ... > > > Lazarus wrote: > > > > > > > I just bought a 1998 sl2. Not 10 minuets after I bought I ran into > > > > some guy that told me that they have a bad problem with breaking > > > > timing chains. > > > > > > I have a 98SL2 with ~75K and since I've had the car (~40K) I've > > never > > > had a problem with the timing belt. I haven't heard anything like > > this > > > (3 other SLs in my family), and I also don't see anything about it > > on > > > the list of TSBs. > > > > > > BTW: does anyone know where to get the full text of the TSBs? All > > I > > > can find is a list of TSB titles, except the 25$/year to alldatadyi. > > > > > > -rj > > > 98SL2 > > > > No timing belt on your car. It has a timing chain. They aren't known > > to break. > > > > Ken > > Saturn timing chains in the 1.9L arent known for strength so yes they > are known to break. Its a single roller chain that goes from the crank > to one or two over head cam(s) so its longer than none ohc engines. I > think there are many ways for these chains to go bad. One may be > sticking valves which stress the chain. Lack of oil changes could result > in more drag. Another thought would be a clogging oil passage that > lubricates the chain. Either way frequent oil changes and not pushing > the engine on a cold winter day until its warmed up can probably greatly > improve the life of the chain. > In most cases that I've heard of, a timing chain breaking on a Saturn is from insufficient maintenance and/or abuse, as you have indicated. I bought my '96 SL2 after it had been repo-ed. I took a chance, since the prior owner didn't seem to have done much better on maintenance than they did on making their payments. Timing chain didn't break, but a piston did. I bought it cheap enough that a self-installed replacement engine made the total cost still reasonable enough. With regular maintenance I've had no problems at approx. 125,000 miles on the '97 engine that now resides under the hood. Ken |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
98 Cherokee 4L I6 Timing Chain - replace? | [email protected] | Jeep | 3 | July 21st 17 01:18 AM |
3.3L V6 - What if I ignore timing chain rattle? | [email protected] | Chrysler | 14 | February 4th 05 04:58 PM |
M50 broken timing chain woes | John Burns | BMW | 9 | December 7th 04 11:33 AM |